AARP/UnitedHealthcare vs Florida Blue Plan G in Florida: How to Compare

By Nathan Curry, licensed Florida insurance agent (license W636941), USA Benefits Group | Last updated October 2026

Quick answer: A Medicare Supplement Plan G from AARP/UnitedHealthcare and a Plan G from Florida Blue pay the same medical benefits, because Medigap plans are standardized by federal law. Both work with any doctor or hospital in the U.S. that accepts Medicare. What can differ is the premium, how each company prices by age, its history of rate increases, its AM Best financial strength rating, household discounts, extras and customer service. We compare both for your age and ZIP code at no cost.

Key points

This is one of the most common questions we get from people turning 65 in Volusia and Flagler, and from people whose premium just went up. Both companies are big names in Florida, and both sell Plan G. Since the benefits are the same, the decision comes down to cost over time and the company behind the policy.

Free help in Florida: we put AARP/UnitedHealthcare, Florida Blue and other Plan G options side by side for your age, ZIP code and household, in South Daytona or by phone, at no cost to you. Book a time or call 386-401-5644.

What is exactly the same

Federal law standardizes Medigap plans by letter. Every Plan G sold in Florida pays:

You pay the Part B deductible ($283 in 2026) each year, and then Plan G covers your share of Medicare-approved costs. Claims go from Medicare to either company automatically. See what Plan G covers for the details.

What can differ between the two

FactorSame or different?What to check
Medical benefitsSameNothing to compare
Doctors and hospitalsSameAny provider that accepts Medicare
Monthly premiumDifferentYour quote for your age, ZIP code, gender and tobacco use
Pricing methodCan differWhether the premium is based on your current age, your age when you buy, or is the same for everyone
Rate increase historyDifferentHow much premiums have risen in Florida in past years
Financial strengthDifferentThe company’s current AM Best rating
DiscountsDifferentHousehold or spouse discounts and payment discounts
MembershipDifferentAARP plans require AARP membership
ExtrasDifferentFitness, hearing, vision or wellness programs, which are not part of the Medigap policy and can change
ServiceDifferentPhone wait times, local presence and how billing questions are handled
Book a Free AppointmentCall 386-401-5644Compare Plans Yourself: Get an Instant Quote

Look at rate history, not just today’s price

The lowest premium at 65 is not always the lowest over 10 or 20 years. Medigap companies raise rates as you age, as medical costs rise and as their group of policyholders changes. A company that starts low can raise rates faster later. Ask for each company’s recent Florida rate increases, and remember that Florida’s Office of Insurance Regulation reviews Medicare Supplement rate filings. Read why Medigap premiums go up in Florida.

Video: Should you buy the cheapest Medicare Supplement?

Nathan Curry explains why the lowest premium today is not the whole story.

Check the AM Best rating

AM Best grades insurance companies on their ability to pay claims. Look up each company’s current financial strength rating on AMBest.com before you buy, since ratings can change. We show you the current rating for each company we quote.

Service and extras

Since the benefits are the same, how a company treats you matters. Think about how easy it is to reach someone, whether there is a local office, how premium billing and bank drafts work, and how quickly questions get answered. Extras such as fitness programs are nice, but they are not part of the Medigap policy and can change, so do not pick on extras alone.

Switching later in Florida

Florida does not have a rule that lets you switch Medigap companies every year without health questions. Outside your Medigap Open Enrollment Period and guaranteed issue situations, a new company can ask about your health and decline you. If you are healthy, it can be worth comparing Plan G prices every few years. If your health changes, staying put may be your only option, which is why rate history matters on day one. See guaranteed issue rights.

Related guides: AARP Medicare Supplement plans in Volusia,Medicare Supplement plans in Florida, What does Plan G cover?, Medigap comparison chart, What Medigap costs in Florida.

Frequently asked questions

Is AARP Plan G better than Florida Blue Plan G?

Neither has better benefits. Plan G is standardized, so both pay the same claims the same way. The differences are price, pricing method, rate increase history, AM Best rating, discounts and service, and the right choice depends on your quote and priorities.

Do I need to be an AARP member to buy an AARP Medicare Supplement plan?

Yes. AARP Medicare Supplement plans, insured by UnitedHealthcare, require AARP membership.

Can I use any doctor with Florida Blue or AARP Plan G?

Yes. Both are Medicare Supplement plans, so they work with any doctor or hospital in the U.S. that accepts Medicare. There is no network.

Can I switch from one Plan G company to another in Florida?

Yes, but outside your Medigap Open Enrollment Period or a guaranteed issue situation, the new company can ask health questions and may decline you.

How do I check a Medicare Supplement company’s financial strength?

Look up the company’s current financial strength rating on AMBest.com. We also show the current rating for each company we quote.

Does it cost more to buy Plan G through a broker?

No. The premium for the same plan from the same company is the same whether you buy through us or directly. The insurance company pays us.

Talk with a local agent

We help people across Volusia, Flagler and Brevard compare Medicare Supplement companies every year, in English and Spanish. Bring your current policy or your Part B start date and we will compare Plan G from multiple companies side by side.

Book a Free AppointmentCall 386-401-5644Compare Plans Yourself: Get an Instant Quote
Nathan Curry, licensed insurance agent in South Daytona, Florida

About the author

Nathan Curry has been a licensed Florida insurance agent for 14 years (Florida license W636941). He works with USA Benefits Group in South Daytona, helping people across Volusia, Flagler and Brevard with Medicare, health, life and disability insurance at no cost to them. Our agency is licensed in 30+ states.

More Medicare guides in our Medicare Education Center

Disclaimer

This page is for general education. Social Security and Medicare make all enrollment and premium decisions. HealthBrokerFL / USA Benefits Group is an independent insurance agency. We are not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program.

We represent all of the Medicare plan organizations available in Volusia County. Please contact Medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE (TTY 1-877-486-2048), 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, or your local State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) to get information on all of your options.

AARP and UnitedHealthcare, and Florida Blue, are independent companies. HealthBrokerFL / USA Benefits Group is not affiliated with or endorsed by either. Company names are used only to answer a common comparison question.